This is the jumbo eye pencil from Benefit,
it is good that it is as black as many girls want
one other thing it is very big and it causes difficulties when you are using it
if you are as clumsy as me, while you are drawing a line to your upper lids, you can also manage to draw lines not only to your lower lids but nearly you can make most of your under eyes black.
it is not waterproof this is the negative part of it
it is also not smudge free as you can see from picture two
yes it gives the dramatic look you desire but it is not water and smudge proof
I have purchased this from Debenhams this winter for 14 GBP
But i do not think i am gonna buy this eye pencil when i finish this one.